top of page

Why Egalitarianism Needs Federalism: A Reply to Joshua Wangia

Writer: Gideon Ong
Gideon Ong
3 hours ago
10 min read
A green highway sign reading "El Paso 145, State Line 16" stands beside a road through dry scrubland under a wide sky.

Opinion pieces reflect the views of their authors, not of Young World Federalists. This is a reply to Joshua Wangia’s essay on Pancivism, which runs alongside it.


Joshua Wangia's essay on Pancivism makes a case every world federalist—and every person—should take seriously: if we reject racism and sexism because they sort people by accidents of birth, we have to reject nationalism for the same reason. As he claims, we need one citizenship and world government to fully effect this. However, he argues that securing the equal worth of humanity needs a single global state, with a relatively stronger central government. I will argue that a federation, with member states whose powers the centre cannot take away, is the better way to secure that same equal citizenship and to keep it from becoming world tyranny.


What is world federalism? At the broadest level, we can think of world federalism as having the goal of peace, peace for all of humanity; peace, for every person, everywhere, not just people who look such-and-such a way, or have such-and-such customs, or believe the “correct” beliefs. World federalists believe, as Lord Lothian put it in 1935, that peace can only be “established by bringing the whole world under the reign of law”; that neither internationalist platitudes nor national supremacism are anything close to a just settlement. World federalism rejects any belief in a moral hierarchy of one man over another, whether fascist, autocratic, or even just “national security” realpolitik. In this manner, world federalism is a big tent, and welcoming to anyone—liberal, socialist, progressive, conservative, Christian, atheist, etc.—who realizes, as Mario Albertini wrote, that their values can “neither be limited to a single country without being demeaned” nor spread beyond it without federalism. This is the world federalism I think many of us first encountered, the world federalism that currently serves as the vanguard of reform towards peace and world government.


Now, in a more specific sense, we can consider world federalism a stricter subset of those above beliefs; in this sense, world federalists not only work for peace, but also believe that a federal structure is the best structure with which to form a world government that would secure peace, justice, liberty, and prosperity for “ourselves and our posterity”. This belief was so prevalent among the early progenitors of the movement that we call both the ‘broad’ and ‘strict’ ideas of world federalism, world federalism. My goal, in this short paper, is to describe to you why so many ‘broad’ world federalists also believe in ‘strict’ world federalism, and to kindly address some points of disagreement with Joshua Wangia’s Pancivism.


First, I want to highlight the point Joshua made, where we cannot “reject racism, sexism, and religious discrimination” without also rejecting nationalism. This is an incredibly important argument that is not said enough, especially in many modern progressive spaces; progressive thought, whether focused on personal liberty, popular rights, or socioeconomic equality, is incoherent within a one-nation framework, and it ends up being corrupted and imprisoned within that framework. Likewise, we cannot work for a world state to protect peace without rejecting all these forms of discrimination—letting discrimination exist in a world state would, at best, be codifying some of the darker impulses of humanity, and at worst, be a gateway drug to totalitarian supremacism.


Joshua’s answer to this is a world-state firmly against national discrimination, committed to erasing borders and having the central power necessary to fight the present evils of both nationalism and the modern polycrisis. This is a noble vision, but in presenting it, and in treating the borders inside a world state as each “simply an internal administrative border” I think he misses some of the genius of our federalist forerunners, and the real and effective ways federal structure can guard against world tyranny and increase and fully realize popular sovereignty.


Joshua’s own example is the line between Shandong and Sichuan. But Shandong and Sichuan are but fictions of Beijing: their powers, and their very borders, depend on the whims of the central government. The same cannot be said of California and Texas, which can and often do challenge Washington. Treating every border as either a wall or a formality erases how people are represented and how power is checked. There is a third kind of border, one that ranks no one’s worth but does divide power. Every citizen holds the same rights, guaranteed by the federation, while the member states and central government are able to check each other’s power.


World tyranny is one of the most commonly-heard charges brought against our quest for world government. I think any supporter of world government for world peace—especially in the United States—has run up against the common misconception that world government implies tyranny. Of course, world government does not at all imply tyranny; in fact, it gives us better tools to prevent tyranny, not least because the threat of war between states is the major contributor to tyrannical state power.


Many of the tools democratic states have developed to ward off the risk of tyranny would be common-sense elements of a world government, some of which are: separation of powers, regular elections, independent judiciaries, and universal suffrage. These are all seen as essential in modern democratic states. They guard against tyranny by limiting the ability of one person or entity to supersede the rule of law, allowing different people to check one another’s powers. In doing this, they bring to life popular sovereignty, the idea and practice that power ultimately comes from the people the government represents, and that to them the government is ultimately responsible.


This popular sovereignty is the sovereignty ‘strict’ world federalists care about, and it is federalism that allows peoples’ sovereignty to be fully realized. States having sovereignty is a holdover from the Westphalian and early-modern era of conflating people, culture, nation and state. Joshua is right that a loose confederation that lets one member switch off the worth of a “foreigner” would be “nationalism tied together with string”—this echoes the critique Hamilton, Jay, and Madison made of the Articles of Confederation. The federalist reform they suggested would have the new, central government derive its power both from the people, as the state governments did, and from the states, and so also be limited and checked in its power by those same state governments, like how the separated branches of government, each with separate powers, check and balance one another. Thus, the different levels of government will themselves allow more representation, more power, and more protection for the people they are made for.


[In a federation] the people, without exaggeration, may be said to be entirely the masters of their own fate. Power being almost always the rival of power, the general government will at all times stand ready to check the usurpations of the state governments, and these will have the same disposition towards the general government. The people, by throwing themselves into either scale, will infallibly make it preponderate. If their rights are invaded by either, they can make use of the other as the instrument of redress. How wise will it be in them by cherishing the union to preserve to themselves an advantage which can never be too highly prized! Alexander Hamilton, Federalist No. 28

If we insist upon one centralized world governance, we run the risk of allowing the same errors that the centralizing nationalist programs had: see, for example, how the schools of the French Third Republic punished children for speaking Breton or Occitan (and France is certainly not unique in this), unchecked by local representation. Federalism protects people in ways the other aforementioned democratic tools cannot; it allows for local representation, for local control, for people to be seen and heard and taken care of in a way a far-off politician in some distant capital cannot do, and it also allows for a central government to solve disputes and address issues common to all people, without disadvantaging less numerous or less fortunate groups. This is the principle of subsidiarity, a principle rooted in Catholic social teaching of the 1930s, which the European Union wrote into its treaties in 1992, and a major practical and theoretical reason why federalism is considered by many to be the best structure for a world government over a diverse humanity.


Joshua says that, under Pancivist governance, “smaller regional leaders would have to answer to the larger global community”. This is a huge and important tool for empowering and freeing people from autocratic regimes, such as the Taliban's Afghanistan, and ensuring common respect for human dignity. However, this accountability should go both ways. The central world governance must itself answer to the people, and one of the most effective ways of making sure this takes place is having already-established routes of representation and advocacy for people, namely the member states of a federation. The balancing act of state versus central government goes some way to answering the worry Joshua raises from the economist Bryan Caplan, that a world government gone wrong would have no free outside world to be compared against or checked by; instead of being external systems, themselves subject to the vagaries of power politics and external threats, the member governments act directly as a check on each other and on the central government, and serve as “laboratories of democracy”.


As a Texan, I would be remiss if I did not include my own people’s history in this discussion, though I will try to keep it brief! Texas’s rebellion against Mexico in 1836 happened in the context of a larger Centralist-Federalist struggle in Mexico; to perhaps oversimplify, many of the regions close to Mexico City preferred a powerful central government, while much of the periphery, from Zacatecas and Texas to Yucatán and the northern states, felt underrepresented and oppressed by a distant central government, and eventually resorted to force of arms to free themselves from what had long been considered to be distant, foreign impositions. Here we see the main issue with centralized governance: it makes people feel drowned out and not represented, that their vote does not matter, nor the issues that affect them, especially over a large area. If it felt like that to the people of 19th-century Mexico, how much more would such be felt across the vaster and more diverse surface of the whole globe? Now, granted, the story of Texan independence in particular is complicated by the significant role the desire for slavery (which Mexico had abolished in 1829) played in the Anglo-Texan desire for independence, spurred on by Southern filibusters; in this, though, notice how an imposition, though extremely moral, by the central government seemed like tyranny to the Texan slaveholders—federalism, as I hope to argue below, has a better chance of spurring grassroots support for moral issues, and a better chance at giving those moral issues the preponderance of political support so that they can change society for the better.


The next huge challenge involving federalism in Texas was the American Civil War. Joshua uses this war and the Confederacy as examples of why elements of the world state should not be allowed to secede. I think this is an important discussion, and it is a point of contentious debate among many modern federalists, but I think that discussion deserves its own essay. Here, I want to show you how the advantages of federalism can be seen, even in the midst of the Civil War.


The Civil War was not a war of a central government versus local communities, it was a war between states in which the Union government and the states of the North, supporting the cause of union and abolition, fought the secessionist slave states. In this case, the weight of both the central government and the support of most of the states was able to settle—though unfortunately it had to be through war—the deep moral issue of slavery. To demonstrate how federalism was useful even in this Civil War, let us consider two alternative timelines: one where the US was closer to a loose confederation and had less central power, and one where it was more centralized and had much less state power. In a loose confederation, as the secessionists claimed the US was, there would have been no central authority strong enough to unify the abolitionist cause nor to eventually impose the emancipation of the slaves and enforce (at least in part) the equality of man. In a centralized state, sure, a moral central government might have defanged and liberated the South without even risking a war; however, southern preponderance in a more centralized government, which it historically had leading up to the Civil War, could just as likely have enshrined slavery, as the Corwin Amendment, passed by Congress in March 1861 but ratified by only a few states, attempted to do by barring federal interference with slavery in the states.


Notice, too, that there has only been one Civil War in the history of the United States. Since then, the advocates, courts and legislators, though suffering turnabouts and backslides, have been successful in generally advancing civil rights and civil liberties. To say one thing about secession: in a well-operating federation, exit is almost never a consideration, since the structural tools exist for people to relieve their grievances by law, and not by war.


Granted, change is often not as fast in a federalist structure as it is in a more centralized one, and I personally would not mind a more powerful central government to more quickly confront the many crises we face today. Nevertheless, with more central power comes less ability to peacefully check it, and with more regional power (or world anarchy, the state we are currently in) likewise comes less ability to peacefully check it. Federalism provides the best ability to functionally build support for change, through first localized reform being proven then spread, as well as the most protection, by adding another layer of checks and balances—and practically, a federal structure is more palatable to most than a distant central government.


Respect for the common dignity of humanity is a cornerstone of world federalism (‘broad’ and ‘strict’), and I believe federalism provides the best path to implement and protect this principle, both from injustice and from tyranny. No matter our various views on the better structure of the desired world-state, we are all united in the recognition of the basic worth of each person, and firm in our conviction of world peace through world law. Whatever our disagreements, let us press on to that goal, together.


Sources


Lord Lothian, “Pacifism Is Not Enough, Nor Patriotism Either”, Burge Memorial Lecture, 1935.


Mario Albertini, “The Strategy of the Struggle for Europe”, in Nationalism, Federalism, and European Integration, p. 190.


“Ourselves and our posterity”: Preamble to the Constitution of the United States.


On progressive thought trapped in a national framework: Altiero Spinelli, “The United States of Europe and the Various Political Tendencies”. The same corruption can also be said of conservative thought, isolationist thought, and so on, but those are topics for other papers.


On war between states as a driver of tyrannical state power: Spinelli’s essay above, and Mathias Koenig-Archibugi, A Universal Republic: A Realistic Utopia?, which examines many of these concerns about world government with some quantitative data.


On divided power: The Federalist, Nos. 28 and 39. Hamilton’s original wording in No. 28 is “In a confederacy”; he used the word for the proposed federal union.


Bryan Caplan, “The Totalitarian Threat” (2008).


“Laboratories of democracy”: Justice Louis Brandeis, dissenting in New State Ice Co. v. Liebmann (1932).


About the author

Gideon Ong is a mechanical engineering and Spanish student in the International Engineering and Language program at the University of Tulsa. A firm Presbyterian and world federalist, he serves on the YWF Board of Directors and helps organize the YWF Book Club, which you can find more about here. You can reach him on the YWF Discord, where he goes by @Gidgo130.

 
 
bottom of page